Carcinoma of the Liver

DEFINITION.—Under the term carcinoma of the liver are included primary and secondary cancer of the liver. The malady with which we are now concerned is the primary affection, occurring in the organ proper or in some pathological new formation connected with it.

ETIOLOGY.—Heredity is the most important factor. A careful investigation of the reported examples demonstrates that from 15 to 20 per cent. owe their origin to hereditary influence clearly, and probably considerably more are indirectly derived in this way when the immediate connection may not be demonstrable. Next to heredity, age must be regarded as the most important pathogenetic influence, much the largest number occurring at from forty to sixty years of age. It is a malady of advanced life, therefore, rather than of youth or middle age. Excluding the female organs from consideration, it is quite certain that sex has little special influence, and that males and females are affected about equally.

Primary cancer of the liver is comparatively infrequent, occurring in not more than one-fourth of the cases. Frerichs collected 91 cases, and of these 46 were secondary to cancer in organs having vascular communication with the liver.

PATHOLOGICAL ANATOMY.—Under the term cancer of the liver are included several distinct forms of morbid growth, but united in the characteristic of malignancy. From the merely clinical standpoint this characteristic is the most decisive bond of union between them, and serves as the point of departure in the study of this affection. Primary cancer of the liver is divisible into two forms: 1, as a single, defined tumor; 2, as an infiltration through the whole mass of the organ. Secondary cancer occurs in nodular masses, and with extreme rarity as an infiltration. The form of cancer is really the same; the differences in structure are only apparent, the variations being due to the relative proportion of cells, fibres, and vessels. If the fibrous stroma is abundant and the cells small in quantity, the form of structure approaches scirrhus; on the other hand, if the cells largely preponderate, the type is encephaloid; if vessels predominate, it is called telangiectatic. The usual form in cancer of the liver is the soft, cellular variety, encephaloid or medullary. When the cancerous new formation is nodular, the masses vary in size from a pea to a child's head, and are numerous inversely as their size. When the cancer occurs as a solitary tumor, it may attain to enormous dimensions. It has a spherical shape usually, protrudes from the surface of the organ somewhat irregularly, and the overlying peritoneum is thickened, cloudy, and adherent from a local inflammation. The central portion, whether there be one, several, or many nodules, is depressed, giving an umbilicated appearance to the tumor; and this central depression is found to be soft, almost diffluent, and full of juice. The fibrous stroma which extends through this central soft material has a reticulated arrangement and a shining, fibrous appearance. The cancerous masses are not confined to these nodules, but extend into the surrounding hepatic structure, push their way into the portal (especially the hepatic) veins, block the ducts, and invade the lymphatic glands in the fissure of the liver.

Virchow, Krankhaften Geschwülste, loc. cit.; Perls, Virchow's Archiv für path. Anat., etc., Band lvi. p. 448 et seq.; Frerichs, A Clinical Treatise, etc., Syd. Soc. ed., loc. cit., vol. ii. p. 281 et seq.

Förster, Lehrbuch der Pathologischen Anatomie, by Seibert, Jena, 1873.

When the cancerous new formation takes the form of an infiltration of the organ instead of distinct nodules, the liver is usually uniformly enlarged and its outlines preserved. The peritoneum is opaque, thickened, and adherent. The organ is traversed by fibrous bands, and the intervening portion is a soft, juicy pulp, stained by the imbibition of bile. In extreme cases hardly any portion of the proper hepatic tissue remains, but is replaced by a cancerous new formation having the same shape.

Perls, Virchow's Archiv, Band lvi. p. 448 et seq.

As regards the minute structure of cancer of the liver, it may be regarded as a degeneration (cancerous) of the proper gland-cells and of the epithelium of the bile-ducts. As cancer develops in the liver it is to be noted that the cellular elements preponderate over the fibrous or the stroma, and hence the new formation presents the characteristics of softness, rapid growth, and a multitudinous cellular hyperplasia. As regards the form of the new cells, it cannot now be doubted that they are descendants of the secretory gland-cells and of the epithelial lining of the ducts. According to some observers, it is to the proliferation of the proper gland-cells that the new formations owe their origin; according to others, to the hyperplasia of the cells lining the ducts. As the growth of the new formation can take place only through an adequate blood-supply, it becomes very important to ascertain its source. There can be little doubt that primary cancer of the liver receives its nutrient supply through the hepatic artery, in connection with which new capillaries form in the pathological tissue.

Secondary cancer of the liver is the usual form of the specific manifestation. From the merely clinical standpoint the primary affection is the more important. From the pathological point of view the secondary implication of the liver may be a true metastasis or a mere communication by contiguity of tissue. The most usual metastasis occurs from epithelial cancer of the face (Schüppel), but the ordinary communication of the new formation is from primary cancer of the stomach, intestine, pancreas, mesentery, etc. The cancer elements, as the author has several times verified, crowd the lymphatics and veins, and through these channels reach the liver and other parts. As the cancer elements in the case of secondary implication of the liver are distributed chiefly by the portal vein, it follows that there must be numerous secondary foci and multiple nodes. Cancerous infiltration under these circumstances is the rarest possible form for the new growth to take. The size and number of nodes forming in these cases of secondary implication of the organ vary greatly—from two or three to twenty, or a hundred, or even more. As regards the form, structure, and ultimate behavior of the secondary formation, they do not differ from the primary. As respects the relative proportion of stroma and cellular elements—fibres and cells—they vary greatly, some presenting the firm texture of a predominating fibrous stroma, others the softness and ready diffluence of the excessive cellular production. The latter is undoubtedly the usual condition, and when the nodular masses are incised an abundant creamy juice exudes. With the development of these nodules an increase in the size of the liver takes place and the organ has an uneven and indurated feel. As the cancerous masses develop the proper hepatic structure undergoes atrophy, and finally little is left of the organ but the cancerous new formation. The blood-vessels, lymphatics, and peritoneal investment are invaded, the first mentioned most decidedly; and especially are organized exudations the favorite seats of cancer new formations, those, for example, about the gall-bladder and cystic duct resulting from repeated attacks of passage of calculi.

Secondary changes take place in the cancerous nodes. As the cells develop pressure is brought to bear on the vessels supplying them and on each other, with the result of fatty degeneration of the central portion, which effects the change in the form of the nodules and in their consistence, already mentioned. The blood-supply to the cancerous nodes in the liver is derived from the hepatic artery, as Frerichs has determined by carefully-made injections; they also are new formations of exceedingly delicate structure, and form a network about the periphery of each mass or node. By reference to these anatomical considerations it is easy to understand the failure of nutrition of the central portions of the nodes.

Pigment cancers of the liver are rare as secondary formations, and excessively infrequent as primary formations. They are, properly speaking, melano-sarcomas (Schüppel). They are more often metastatic than merely secondary—that is, transferred from different parts, as in the case of melanotic sarcoma of the choroid—than due to neighboring disease transferred by contiguity of tissue. This variety of cancer, so called, takes the form of multiple nodes or of diffused infiltration, the former more frequently; but both modes of development may go on at the same time. The nodes vary in size from a pea to a child's head, have a grayish, brownish, or blackish tint, and exude on section a fluid not creamy like true cancer-juice, but rather watery and containing black particles floating in it. In the case of diffuse infiltration the pigment masses are thoroughly distributed through the original hepatic tissue. In both forms the size and weight of the organ are enormously increased. In the case of the melanotic infiltration the whole organ is uniformly enlarged, reaching in a few months the enormous size of twelve to twenty pounds.

Sarcomas also occur very rarely as primary growths in the liver, but secondary sarcomas are more frequent. There are fibro-sarcoma, lympho-sarcoma, and osteo-sarcoma as secondary deposits, the first being very firm in consistence, the second soft and medullary, and the last of hard, bony consistence.

SYMPTOMS.—We are especially concerned here with primary cancer of the liver. The secondary disease is so obscured by the main and primary lesion that a diagnosis may be impossible. Furthermore, the progress of the original disease is that which demands immediate consideration. As, therefore, the secondary implication of the liver is of relatively trifling importance, and only an incident in the course of the main disease, the matter for consideration now is primary cancer of the liver.

It is the fact that in some, even a considerable proportion, of the cases the onset and progress of cancer of the liver are very obscure. For some time the symptoms may be of the vaguest description. The usual history is this: A person of forty to sixty years begins to fail in flesh and strength, becomes sallow, has disorders of digestion, pain and uneasiness in the right hypochondrium, and the bowels are now confined, now relaxed. The abdomen, notwithstanding the general loss of flesh, increases in size, and the superficial veins are enlarged; very considerable pain is experienced in the right hypochondrium, and often extreme tenderness to pressure is a pronounced symptom. The pains are not limited to the hepatic region, out extend widely from this point in all directions. On palpation the liver is found to be enlarged, its texture indurated, and its outline irregular and nodular, and pain—often, indeed, quite severe—is developed by pressure.

The condition of the liver on palpation is best ascertained by suddenly depressing the abdominal wall with the tips of the fingers arranged in a line. Displacing thus the movable bodies in the cavity, the liver is quickly reached, and nodules, if they exist, are readily felt. If the new formation has developed from exudations about the gall-bladder and cystic duct, it may be felt by suddenly depressing the walls of the abdomen over this organ in the usual position of the fissure.

In the case of general cancerous infiltration of the organ, with the remarkable enlargement which occurs in such cases, there will be present an obvious distension of the right hypochondrium; the intercostal spaces will be forced outward and the arches of the ribs rendered more prominent; the area of hepatic dulness, both vertical and transverse, will be increased; and the limits of dulness will move with a full inspiration downward, and with a full expiration upward. This mobility of cancer-nodules of the liver with the inspiratory and expiratory changes serves to distinguish them from tumors of the abdominal walls. Seen early, the changes in the size of a nodule or of the liver itself may be noted from week to week, especially in cases of rapidly-growing cancer.

Murchison, Clinical Lectures, p. 187.

As the cancerous new formations extend into the portal system within the liver, obstruction to the portal circulation results from the blocking of the blood-current. Also, interference in the portal circulation arises by compression of the vessels from without, either through the accumulation of cancer-products in the liver or by the enlargement of the lymphatics in the fissure of the organ. In what way soever it may be produced, the practical fact remains that ascites is a frequent symptom, occurring in somewhat more than one-half of the cases. The character of the fluid varies. It may be a clear serum containing a small proportion of albumen; it may be colored by bile or be of a deeper greenish or reddish hue; it may contain flocculi of lymph and numerous leucocytes floating in it; and the ordinary serum may be rendered cloudy and be filled with shreds of exudation in consequence of peritonitis, or bloody because of hemorrhage from a softening nodule. When the fluid is considerable in amount the difficulty of ascertaining the condition of the liver is greatly enhanced, and symptoms due to the interference of the fluid with the action of various organs are introduced into the complexus of morbid signs. Especially is the upward pressure of the ascitic fluid, and the consequent interference in the movements of the lungs and heart, a source of considerable distress. First, a local and afterward a general peritonitis ensues as a consequence of the extension outwardly of the new formations to the peritoneal layer, and its implication by contiguity of tissue or the rupture of a spreading fungous growth and hemorrhagic extravasation into the cavity. The peritoneal complication is not only a serious addition to the sufferings experienced by the patient, but it adds to the difficulties of a diagnosis. In the case of a celebrated savant who died of cancer of the liver (seen by the writer) there was such a pronounced peritonitis that the diagnosis made by the attending physician was chronic peritonitis. When this complication occurs, there takes place a decided increase in the local tenderness, and this increased sensibility to pressure quickly extends over the abdomen, causing a general exquisite tenderness. Besides this tenderness characteristic of most cases of peritonitis, distension of the abdomen and the decubitus peculiar to this state are obvious symptoms. It is therefore clear that the occurrence of peritonitis not only contributes to the severity and painfulness of the case, but seriously complicates the diagnosis.

It has been already stated that pain in the right hypochondrium is a nearly constant symptom in cancer of the liver. With the initial symptoms, uneasiness, heaviness, a sense of pressure in the hepatic region are experienced, and as the case progresses more or less acute pain develops as a rule. But there are exceptions. In cases of cancer involving the deeper portion of the liver there may be little pain, and in some rare cases of cancer involving the external part of the liver—the capsule and peritoneum—but little pain is experienced. In much the largest proportion of cases the pain is severe, and the production of any considerable pain means the implication of the hepatic plexus of nerves or the hepatic peritoneum. It follows, then, that the pain in the former case is not limited to the locality of the disease, but is more or less widely distributed through the anatomical relations of the hepatic plexus, being felt in the epigastrium, the walls of the chest, the shoulders, etc.

In secondary cancer of the liver, following cancer of the stomach, vomiting is a constant symptom, but also in those cases of primary disease in which the left lobe is especially enlarged, relatively, are nausea and vomiting pronounced symptoms. At the onset of the malady the appetite fails and a gastro-intestinal catarrh is set up. More or less catarrh of the bile-ducts also ensues. The interference with nutrition thus occasioned is enhanced in those cases in which the obstruction of the ducts is sufficient to prevent the escape of bile into the intestine. Jaundice is not a constant symptom, occurring in little more than one-third of the cases. When it occurs, the peculiar stools are present and the intestinal digestion is deranged, as in cases of ordinary obstruction to the ducts. In two cases of cancer of the liver occurring in the writer's practice, and examined by post-mortem, there were calculi present in the gall-bladder; in one case the principal calculus was egg-shaped and the size of a pullet's egg.

The nutrition rapidly fails from the beginning of cancer of the liver. The downward pace is accelerated when the gastro-intestinal digestion fails and vomiting occurs after taking food. The skin becomes dry and wrinkled, and if not jaundiced has a peculiar tint, varying in depth of color from an earthy or fawn-like hue to a deep bronze. Failure of strength is a pronounced symptom from the beginning, and is out of proportion to the loss of flesh. As the wasting advances the decline of strength is accounted for, but the feeling of weakness and the distaste for exertion which occur so early are very significant signs of internal cancer, although they do not indicate the position of the neoplasm. Emaciation finally becomes extreme.

The urine declines in amount as the case progresses. It is usually very high-colored, contains bile-pigment when jaundice is present, and other forms of pigment produced by conditions not at present known. Sometimes albumen is present, and leucin and tyrosin rarely.

COURSE, DURATION, AND TERMINATION.—As has been already set forth, cancer of the liver may present so few really distinctive symptoms as to escape recognition. Under favorable circumstances the diagnosis may be comparatively easy. In forming an opinion it is useful to review the whole course of the malady and draw conclusions not only from the characteristic signs, but from the development of the symptoms as a whole.

A case of cancer of the liver occurs usually after the middle period of life. The person so affected begins to decline in flesh and strength, has uneasiness in the right hypochondrium, disorders of digestion, and begins to have a pallid or earthy hue of the countenance. Presently, much pain is felt in the hepatic region, the organ distinctly enlarges, and some effusion of fluid and much flatus increase the dimensions of the abdomen. Much tenderness, often exquisite sensibility, is produced by pressure over the liver, and often over the whole abdomen. By careful palpation nodules can be made out and their growth noted in those cases free from peritoneal inflammation. The abdominal swelling and tenderness incommodes the lungs, and a semi-erect decubitus is assumed to relieve the pressure on them; the breathing becomes short, catching, hurried, and painful, and sometimes a most distressing hiccough is superadded to the other sufferings. Great wasting and weakness ensue. Jaundice appears, or the earthy hue of the skin deepens into a bronze discoloration. The case may be terminated by some intercurrent disease—by an attack of pleuritis, pneumonia, by peritonitis from rupture or perforation, by intra-peritoneal hemorrhage, by an exhausting diarrhoea. The natural termination is by gradual failure of the powers, by marasmus, the immediate cause of death being due to cerebral anæmia, to failure of the heart from fatty degeneration of the cardiac muscle, from thrombosis of the portal vein, from the development of a hemorrhagic state, and hemorrhages from the various mucous surfaces, etc. The duration is much influenced also by the character of the cancer, whether scirrhous or medullary. The latter are not only more rapidly growing, more destructive of the hepatic tissue, and more rapidly distributed to neighboring organs, but more quickly perforate the capsule and excite a fatal result by hemorrhage or by peritonitis. The average duration of cancer of the liver is variously stated. Having reference to my own personal observation, controlled by the experience of other observers, the duration is from three to nine months, one year being exceptional. There are cases in which the symptoms are very acute, the progress rapid, the whole course from the initial symptoms to the termination being completed in from two to three months. It need hardly be observed that no case of cancer of the liver has been cured. The invariable termination is in death. If any case has seemed to be cured, it may be asserted with confidence that cancer of the liver did not exist.

DIAGNOSIS.—The differential diagnosis is concerned, first, with the existence of cancer; second, with its form. As cancer causes enlargement of the liver in two textural conditions—namely, uniformly smooth, and nodular—it must be differentiated from other diseases producing similar results. Amyloid disease and echinococcus cysts present us types of the former; cirrhosis and syphilis, of the latter. The history of the amyloid disease and of the echinococcus cyst is very different, and both develop much more slowly. Amyloid disease of the liver arises simultaneously with the same form of degeneration in other organs, and is connected with suppurative disease of some kind, with syphilis, with chronic malarial poisoning, etc., and may occur at any age. Echinococcus cysts enlarge painlessly and do not impair the vital forces; the liver is elastic, and under favorable circumstances presents by palpation the purring-tremor symptom. Cirrhosis may have to be differentiated at two periods—during the time of enlargement, which, however, is rather brief; and during the stage of contraction and nodulation. The history in cancer and in cirrhosis is different: the age, the habits of life, the rate of hepatic change, are opposed in the two diseases; the diminution in size with nodulation is characteristic of cirrhosis; enlargement with nodulation belongs to cancer. The rapid progress of cancer, the wasting, the debility, the cachexia, serve to distinguish it from all other affections of the liver except acute yellow atrophy and phosphorus-poisoning; both, however, are so different in history and development as not to require differentiation. It may be quite impossible in latent cases to distinguish primary cancer of the liver from secondary, but in those examples of the disease occurring in the stomach, intestines, and pancreas there is usually an antecedent history of the primary malady which distinctly separates it in point of time and the character of the symptoms from the secondary implication of the liver. Cancer of the gall-bladder, and especially of the organized exudation about it, may not be readily separated from cancer of the pancreas or of the duodenum. In doubtful cases the history of attacks of hepatic colic becomes an important element in making the differentiation.

TREATMENT.—As we are not in possession of a cure for cancer, the treatment of cancer of the liver must be palliative. Anodynes to relieve pain, paracentesis of the abdomen to remove accumulation of fluid which causes distress, carbolic acid to check nausea and vomiting, and the usual hæmostatics for hemorrhage, are the measures most necessary. In fact, the treatment must be throughout symptomatic—for the relief of symptoms as they arise.